PFN maintains multiple Network Groups that are expected to be key generators of PFN ideas, thinking, and content about US policy topics and solutions. Each Network Group is focused on a broad policy area (“Domain”), officially recognized by the PFN Leader, and made up of Network Group Participants, both Members and Collaborators.
For starters, PFN maintains these four Domains: Artificial Intelligence & Robotics, Government Structure & Processes, Retirement & Aging, and Socio-Economic Levels & Mobility. Each Domain will typically encompass 15 to 20 specific policy topics, though some will have fewer and some more.
See the PFN Overview Infographic for how the roles fit together.
Capitalized terms that this document does not define have the meanings given in the PFN Glossary. See Related Content below.
Recognizing and Retiring a Network Group
A Network Group and its Domain exist within PFN only when the PFN Leader officially recognizes them. Once the PFN Leader does so, the PFN Leader designates the Network Group Leader, a role the PFN Leader may fill personally. The PFN Leader may withdraw recognition of a Network Group or a Domain at any time, in the PFN Leader’s sole discretion.
When a Network Group is retired, its Participants lose their Network Group access, and the Domain is removed from the Website header and menus. PFN may archive the Network Group’s Exploratory Content for possible future use. Other content that had been restricted to the Network Group may be opened to Basic Participants, except for Exploratory Content, which stays restricted.
A Participant’s access to a Network Group also ends when the person stops being a PFN Participant.
What a Network Group Does
Once the PFN Leader recognizes a Network Group and its Domain, the Network Group is responsible for maintaining a Domain Overview that defines the meaning and scope of its Domain and the more specific policy topics the Domain covers.
A Network Group’s Participants are (a) Basic Participants who have been approved as Members of the Network Group and its Domain and (b) PFN Collaborators working on a specific project or activity within the Network Group’s Domain. They can access all content on the PFN website relevant to the Network Group’s Domain and can engage with each other in protected or restricted-access discussion and debate areas, through online comment and discussion forums, in-person and virtual meetings, and exchanges on draft articles and reports.
Most importantly, a Network Group’s Participants work together on articles and other PFN content, including Solution Reports, about the policy topics and solutions the Network Group has decided to prioritize. Solution Reports are PFN’s flagship publication: each Report is a long-form article presenting a policy solution along with the strongest statements in favor of it, the strongest objections to it, and the leading alternatives. Completed Solution Reports are publicly available. See About Solution Reports, which presents the requirements that PFN applies to Solution Report projects.
Network Groups in Practice
Network Groups are expected to produce Next-Level ideas, thinking, solutions, and content. Next-Level means going beyond restating what is expected or already known to identify something new and different, improve a solution in a way its own proponents welcome, or make a solution and its pro and con arguments clearer and more useful.
Network Group Participants are expected to hold to their views when collaborating with others, particularly when working on policy solutions, PFN content, or Solution Reports. Participants should not abandon or compromise their views just to reach consensus, as PFN believes that this would generally produce less substantive, less rigorous, and less innovative thinking. Participants are also expected to be constructive collaborators with each other, particularly when they disagree with the views, solutions, and arguments under development.
A consequence of this approach is that a single Network Group is likely to produce different, even conflicting solutions and Solution Reports on the same topic. Some may see this as a problem, but PFN believes the best way to develop Next-Level ideas is for experts with a diversity of views to advance their own views firmly while engaging constructively with those who hold different and even conflicting views.
Each Network Group should conduct its discussions, debate, and solution development under the rules in the PFN Code of Conduct, including the Chatham House Rule, the constructive collaboration guidelines, and the restricted-access Exploratory Content rules. And when working on Solution Reports, each Network Group and its project team should adhere to the various baseline and other requirements applicable to Solution Report projects. See About Solution Reports.
Building a Network Group
PFN believes that Network Groups and their Leaders should consider several steps to help Participants become more effective constructive collaborators and to build Network Groups into high-performing teams.
- Participants should read and discuss the Network Group’s Domain Overview and review third-party content on the PFN website that falls within the Domain. The Domain Overview is written to be neutral with respect to the competing views within the Domain, so it serves as a common starting point.
- Participants should prepare their own individual sketches about the topics in the Domain they think matter most, why they matter more than others, the policy directions they’re interested in, and what they think people who disagree with them get right and wrong. These sketches can then be shared and discussed within the Network Group, in writing or as part of discussions.
- Participants should meet to discuss selected policy topics and solutions, sometimes with invited experts.
- Participants may research selected topics and solutions and share the results with other Participants for discussion and with PFN for possible publication on the PFN website.
- Participants may prepare articles and other short content about policy solutions. Short items carry less risk and cost than more extensive articles and reports like Solution Reports, and working together on short items may help Participants get more comfortable with constructive collaboration techniques and behaviors.
- The Network Group should bring the Participants’ sketches together into an integrated picture, such as a map of viewpoints, showing where Participants agree, overlap, and diverge. Mapping the different views should help Participants identify patterns and work with each other, and should help the Network Group set its priorities, projects, and other activities.
- The Network Group should choose the policy topics and solutions it wants to prioritize, the meetings it wants to hold, and the content and Solution Reports it wants to develop. The larger the Network Group, the more of each it should be able to take on.
- The Network Group should develop a plan to push forward on those decisions.
- The Network Group should share its plan with the PFN Leader for feedback and possible modifications. In some cases, the PFN Leader can help implement a plan, for example by recruiting other experts to projects to assure an adequate diversity of views, or by assigning a PFN Writer to work with the Network Group on content, particularly Solution Reports.
Related Content
PFN Content. About Constructive Collaboration · About Domain Overviews · About Solution Reports · About Policy Futures Network · About PFN Content and Statement Types · Chatham House Rule · PFN Code of Conduct · PFN Glossary · PFN Overview Infographic.
Acknowledgements
Contributors. Harry Conaway (PFN Leader) is the author and writer of this content and is solely responsible for its substance.
Disclosures. Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic) was used to assist in editing this content. All substantive and writing decisions were made by the author and writer noted in the Contributors section above.
PFN Content Type. This content is classified as PFN about and governing content, and thus is not subject to PFN’s Content and Statement Types policy for substantive policy content.
Version History
Current Version. To be added